This was started on 9 Aug 2007, in the Preston Library, with various edits between then and the arrival at semi-consistent internet.
Don’t let anybody tell you that free internet in the library is just as good as having it at home. Today we spent two hours in the library in Preston (Lancashire, UK) library using their free internet, and it’s nothing close to the experience we left behind in Morris or the connectivity we hope to establish in Colchester.
The problem isn’t the library – it’s a very nice library, and they provided fine facilities (if the connection itself was a bit slow). The problem isn’t really that you have to wait in line (or book in advance), or that you have to use their equipment and annoying IE browser, or that you have no control over the facilities. (Although all these things are certainly a significant nuisance.) The problem is that the value of so much of the Internet is simply that it’s there, at your beck and call when you need it, and that just don’t work in hour long blocks once a week.
When my mom was a kid, they had the standard references (encyclopedia, dictionary) right near the dining table so they could be quickly consulted when a question arose during dinner. This was, in its way, the 1940′s/1950′s version of having a proxy library nearby. It was also the 1970′s version as well, and I still remember our family’s purchase of a World Book Encyclopedia in 1972. Over the years I read very large parts of that many volumed beast, and it was a great resource for a growing kid.
Now, however, traditional print encyclopedias have been almost entirely eclipsed by the amazing range and currency of on-line sources. The encyclopedia I grew up with was purchased in 1972, which means that as far as it was concerned nothing in the world changed after that moment in time. (There were annual yearbooks that we got for quite a while after, but their integration was limited at best, and I don’t remember using them much.) Thus that encyclopedia (which my parents still have) knows nothing about the end of the Soviet Union and the fall of the Iron Curtain, nothing about two Iraq wars, and nothing about personal computers and the Internet itself.
Sure, Wikipedia has its issues, and Google doesn’t always drive you directly to what you’re looking for, but they beat the tar out of that old 1972 encyclopedia. For a library at your fingertips, there has never been anything in human history that comes close to the power of the net. A key part of that value, however, is the “at your fingertips” bit, and that just doesn’t work if you’re scheduling your internet time in two hour blocks days or weeks in advance.
This isn’t to say that I wouldn’t want free internet in libraries. I could see wanting to read or do research in a library (some people like that atmosphere), and wanting to be able to quickly look something up on-line. I finally finished Neil Gaiman’s excellent Sandman series this summer, and there were all manner of odd references that I would look up while I was reading. At home I’d just grab a laptop and Google; if I was instead reading in a library or a coffee shop or at the University, I’d want to be able to do essentially the same.
All of which is another way of saying I want on-line access on demand all the time, even if it pains me to admit it. And I want it for my son, and my students, and everyone else as well. I realize that this comes with risks; I taught a summer class for kids from 9 to 17, and getting them off of IM and Facebook and the host of other on-line distractions was not a trivial thing. My guess, though, is that we will, over time, learn to manage those risks, and that they’ll be outweighed by the benefits of ready access to so much information.
Sadly, this is also probably ultimately an argument for the ubiquity of web enabled cell phones and similar devices. I’m not really a big fan of cell phones. They generally (in my experience) have much poorer sound quality than a good land-line phone, “I’m on the train!” is truly obnoxious, and I’m not sure I want to be that available (people already find me enough as it is!). Still, ubiquitous (and perhaps embedded) computing devices with the ability to access the web are increasingly a reality and almost certainly represent the future.
And in that future, we’ll all have that library at our fingertips all the time, whether we’re in the library or not.
2 Comments
My folks bought us a set of encylopedias when I was growing up. 1977 I think. I recently took the giant box full of the entrie set (nearly destroying my back) out of my folks basement and into Half Price Books. The guys at the counter was very plesant. He gave me a dollar for my efforts. Those books are just going to get re-pulped. If they had been another 30 years older, they might have been interesting. As it was, they were just out of date.
I have to say that there is a positive world to be said for spine-bound knowledge. There is a method of exploration in books (the dictonary for example) that is very difficult to acheive electronically.
Yikes! Well, we better hang on to my parents’ set for another few decades, then. There are probably a lot of old encyclopedias and dictionaries headed out to landfills these days, which is sort of sad.
I agree with the value of browsing. It’s one of the things I miss about “real” bookstores and libraries. On several occassions I’ve found very cool things that were just down the shelf from what I was officially looking forward. The “Recommended if you like…” stuff at Amazon provides a similar function (and perhaps more focussed), but it is a qualitatively different experience.