Oh, yeah, I definitely had the Flickr problems (and GMail’s issues in Germany) in the back of my mind as I wrote this. There’s also the whole business of Google aiding the Chinese government in limiting what their citizens can find (through Google) on-line.
You raise several excellent questions. One thing that the Flickr situation raises, though, is the problem when the rules (or their interpretation) change after you’ve signed up and paid your money. I doubt that many German users of Flickr ever expected these problems when they plopped down their Euros; my guess is that most of them expected Flickr to defend their ability to participate fully in the community (which is arguably not what happened).
I’m really torn on this, which is why I haven’t posted about it yet. I’m frankly very frustrated by what Flickr has done, but I also realize that they’re caught in a difficult position. The fact that Google is running up against similar problems in Germany from a different angle helps point out how complex the issues are (at least at a corporate level).
]]>Holy crap! I’m not feeling well enough today to launch into this topic, but you have put down an excellent foundation here! This ties directly into the trouble that flickr has been having lately. The question SAH and I have raised is does a free service owe you (the end user) the same courtsey/rules as a pay site? Once you pay for a service, don’t you agree to their rules? Do internet sites owe the user anything at all?
Wow. Seriously. Great topic.
]]>