Warning: Constant ABSPATH already defined, this will be an error in PHP 9 in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-config.php on line 22
Nic McPhee – Page 367 – I am … unhindered by talent

It’s a shame more people can’t write so well about tech


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

John Naugton
WeatherGirl just handed me a recent copy of The Observer, an excellent British weekly that she subscribes to as part of her campaign (along with listening to BBC radio on-line) to both keep track of what’s happening “back home” and to get her news from organizations that regularly provide intelligent, thoughtful reporting.

An excellent example of this is John Naughton, the author of a regularly technology column in the Observer, and the author of the piece WeatherGirl was handing my way. The column in question is an analysis of the recent (and much discussed) Supreme Court decision regarding Grokster and StreamCast Networks which has been seen by many as a huge defeat for the peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing, and victory for the big players in corporate media that are trying to desparately to maintain at least the illusion of their control over their content.

Most writing on this and similar issues tends to suffer from serious myopia as the writers typically understand either the technological side of the issue or the socio-political-economic side of the issue. It is sadly all too common that writers understand neither of these sides, and very rarely do they understand both. Naughton is the happy exception, who really understands the world of the nerds that drive the technical changes that constantly ripple through our lives, and can write with wonderful perception about the larger context that these issues live in.

In the column in question, for example, Naughton understands (and clearly explains) important differences between Grokster and StreamCast Networks and the classic Sony decision that is often quoted as precedent. As he nicely points out, a better analogy to the Sony decision is BitTorrent, yet sadly most writers on the issue (not to mention many of the policy makers involved) probably know little about BitTorrent and less about its place in this complex set of issues.

In short, John rocks, and you could do much worse.

Oh, and I should mention that he also helps support the interesting Living without Microsoft site.

Go George Go!


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

George Hincapie wins Stage 15 of the 2005 Tour de France!
Yesterday’s stage win by George Hincapie in the 2005 Tour de France was, barring something quite remarkable in the final week, my highlight of this year’s (excellent) Tour. In fact, it may well be the highlight of quite a few Tours!

Road racing like the Tour is held together by a very complex network of social interactions built on rich interactions of competition and trust, as well as decades of tradition. It’s full of shifting alliances and challenges, many of which lend themselves to a Prisoner’s Dilemma style analysis.

Hincapie has supported Lance Armstrong for years, being the only rider to be on his team in each of Lance’s 6 (and now very likely 7) Tour victories. Yet, until yesterday, George had never won a Tour stage. He’d had considerable success in other races, but never a Tour stage. In fact no one on one of Lance’s teams (except, of course, Lance himself) had ever won a Tour stage. Yesterday was the reward for all those years of hard work and loyalty. Like the best rewards, though, it wasn’t a gift – Lance didn’t “let him win”. Sure, the team allowed him to remain in the breakaway, and you can bet they would have told him to wait if Lance had found himself in difficulty. But it was George that stayed with the leaders throughout an absolutely killer series of vicious climbs, and it was George that took the sprint at the end. When you have over 100 extraordinarily talented cyclists in the race no one, not even someone as powerful as Lance Armstrong, can promise, ensure, or dictate anything. No one could give this to George, which I’m sure makes it all the sweeter.

By eric osguthorpe
To see the emotion on George’s face when he crossed the line, and the embrace when Lance came in a bit later, was right up there (for me) with great moments like The Look.

Lance has never won a Tour without winning at least one stage, and I think there’s always (almost always?) been at least one mountain stage win. The mountain top finishes are done for the year, and Lance has yet to win a stage, so the most likely remaining opportunity will be the final time trial. I suspect, though, that even though Lance will probably be disappointed if he doesn’t win at least one stage on his way to a historic seventh Tour victory, yesterday’s win by George Hincapie will come damn close to making up for it.