Warning: Constant ABSPATH already defined, this will be an error in PHP 9 in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-config.php on line 22
Nic McPhee – Page 390 – I am … unhindered by talent

Our last radio show of the school year is tomorrow!


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58


The U-90 Alternative
I put 2 and 2 together and realized that tomorrow (Sunday, 8 May 2005, 2-4pm) is our last radio show of the 2004-2005 school year – yikes! No cool guests scheduled like last week, but it should still be fun in a more typical Unhindered By Talent sort of way (whatever the hell that means!). So tune in at 89.7FM if you can see UMM’s spiffy new wind turbine from your house, and the rest of you can listen on-line.

Sorry, by the way for the complete silence over the last week. The end of the semester is kicking me about the room, and I’m currently trying to get things ready for the Genetic Programming in Theory and Practice (GPTP) workshop in Ann Arbor next week. Going to a workshop during the second half of finals week just wasn’t the smartest plan. The interview with Dr. Reagon was a complete blast, and her concert with the UMM Choir on Tuesday was really something. I really need to say more soon before it completely leaves my head, but there are too many fires to put out first.

If you’re in desparate need of a fix, WeatherGirl‘s life settled down a tad and she had a fun flurry of posting last week in my absence. Her “Madness in the mid-west” post is particularly recommended both for her comments on the whole “Cootie shots” silliness and her archiving of the substantial number of excellent letters sent to the local paper on the issue. There’s some great stuff there, and gives one reasons for optimism in the fight against ill-informed bigotry. (I also recommend PZ’s comments here and there.)

Finally, I should also point out that it snowed here on both the 1st and 2nd of May. There are days when I truly wonder why human beings actual establishment settlements this far north.

A draft of a Strib letter on the neo-creationism silliness


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

I’ve just spent way too long flailing away in the horribly cramped confines of 150 words trying to write a letter to the Minneapolis Star-Tribune on the whole ID-in-schools silliness. I wrote about a zillion drafts, and WeatherGirl expertly poked holes in one after another, sending me back to the drawing board time after time. Gotta love having a wonderful editor across the kitchen table, but it’s darn frustrating when you just want to get the thing done and turn it in. Fuss, whine, moan – rinse until done.

So, after much work, we’ve gotten to here:

In his 23 April piece, Dave Eaton is clearly unable to critically examine the complexities of the “Intelligent Design” debate or understand the underlying scientific issues. He starts by seriously misrepresenting the state of the debate in evolutionary biology in a desperate attempt to create the illusion of a crisis when none exists. He then suggests that ID should have some place in our science curriculum. Yet Paul Nelson, a major spokesperson for the ID cause, recently admitted in a talk here at UM-Morris that to date ID had no scientifically testable hypotheses to offer.

Until ID can bring such hypotheses to the table, it should not and cannot play a meaningful role in our science curriculum. ID may have a useful role to play in a course on creation myths, but not in our children’s science courses.

Thoughts or suggestions are most welcome, although I’ll need to send this off tomorrow night (Sunday, 1 May).

For those with a twisted interest in the painful birth pangs of this letter (and as evidence for my students and son when they complain about all my scribbles on their work), I’m actually including an abridged history below the fold of how we ended up with this draft.

Continue reading “A draft of a Strib letter on the neo-creationism silliness”