Warning: Constant ABSPATH already defined, this will be an error in PHP 9 in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-config.php on line 22
Computing – Page 61 – I am … unhindered by talent

Technology, communication, and dissent


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

Mixed signals at twilight
Thursday I’m guesting in Paula and Chris’s Summer Scholars class (Talking About a Revolution: Dissent and Freedom of Expression in Today’s World). I’m being brought in as a “tech head” to talk about how technology plays into these questions, so I’m going to jot down a few thoughts.

First, dissent (or at least effective dissent) fundamentally requires communication. If people wish to change things, they presumably have to convey their dissent in order to make a difference, raising awareness, explaining the issues, and recruiting support. Second, the mechanics of and opportunities for communication have and continue to be defined by technology, and the rapid changes in technologies certainly affect communication, and consequently dissent.

Consider, for example, McCarthy and Murrow a la Good night and good luck. McCarthy used the technology of Congress (and I use technology extremely broadly here) to create his bully pulpit and communicate his ideas. Murrow, in turn, used his access to the still young technology of television to communicate his alternative view. Similarly, the Dixie Chicks can use the technology of music recording, radio, and public performance to object to Bush’s policies, but at the same time large media conglomerates like Cumulus Media can ban the Dixie Chicks’ music from their 300+ radio stations, potentially limiting the impact of that dissent.

So to understand the impact of technology on dissent, we have to think about how they affect our communications. Key, though, is to think about who a technology allows to be a speaker, and who is forced to be a listener. Who does the technology empower, and who loses opportunities? Jerry Mander, for example, encourages us to

Make distinctions between technologies that primarily serve the individual or the small community (for example, solar energy) and those that operate on a scale of community control (for example, nuclear energy).

So, are the internet and the web the great savior of free speech (and dissent), or shall just another controlling arm of corporate and government interests?

Discuss.

And maybe librarians can start pasting ads in books?


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

Christina's Strip Mall by t-squared

TechCrunch shares the disturbing news that some bright bulb has developed software that allows ISPs to insert ads into web pages as they pass through the ISPs servers. The user is then unable to tell the difference between ads that are “supposed” to be there (and presumably benefit the creator of the content they’re perusing) and ads inserted by their ISP without the knowledge or consent of the author(s) of the web pages in question. Quoting TechCrunch:

As a content creator I’m horrified that any page I create could be plastered with advertisements I don’t approve of as I’m sure many others will be as well. There are probably copyright issues as well in terms of hijacking original works for profit. We can only hope that this evil form of advertising does not spread beyond Texas.

This blog, for example, is free of ads so far, and is likely to remain so for the foreseeable future. We simply don’t get enough traffic to warrant such things. You, however, might be seeing it with ads that I know nothing about, which put no money in my pocket, and without you being aware that I didn’t put them there.

Ugly as this is, the extreme case is truly horrifying. Potentially every server that passes along your HTML packets could be inserting ads and otherwise altering or rearranging content. We could reach a point where the page viewed bears almost no resemblance to the page served, totally undermining any and all efforts to introduce some reasonable design principles to this intarweb thing. (Not to mention all the privacy and censorship issues that would naturally arise.)

As useful as I find blogs like TechCrunch and Pharyngula, for example, both are already horribly blighted by oceans of ads, many of which blink, move, wiggle, and jump in ways that make me want to beat someone publicly. And those ads are placed there by the people that run (or at least manage) those sites, who have a vested interest in not making their web pages so awful people just won’t go there. ISPs will have no such compunction because they’ll pollute everything equally, so their only real risk is annoying their users so much that they switch ISPs (not always an easy option) or simply stop going on-line (which would take a lot of annoying).

I suspect, however, that encryption could do a lot to solve this problem. I haven’t thought through the details, but I suspect that encrypting all web pages using something like https would make it impossible for ISPs to insert their ads because they’d no longer have access to the raw HTML. It would cause an increase in the amount of traffic on-line (encrypted information is almost always larger than its raw, unencrypted form), but I suspect this would be nothing compared to all the traffic generated by YouTube. And I’m betting nearly everyone would gladly wait a tiny fraction of a second longer for their page to download and decrypt if it kept it free of all this ISP spam. What would be nasty is if encryption schemes ran contrary to the powerful monitoring urges of governments; it would really suck to drown in spam just so Big Brother can keep an eye on what crazy music I’m listening to on-line.