Warning: Constant ABSPATH already defined, this will be an error in PHP 9 in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-config.php on line 22
Computing – Page 80 – I am … unhindered by talent

Are there interesting affordances of mind mapping?


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58


seismograph #4, originally uploaded by Nils K. Windisch (netomer).

Bill over at Notional Slurry has been wondering whether the mind mapping emperor actually has any clothes. Which is a fine bit of timing, because I’d been wondering the same thing. In all the driving back and forth to Arkansas to help out with Dad, I speculatively downloaded a bunch of different podcasts onto the aged iPod including (nerdly, I do confess) some stuff on software development and project management. Much of it was, sadly, crap, but it kept me awake so I won’t be too harsh.

Somewhere in all that was a mention of mind mapping, so I figured I’d dust that idea off again and see if it made any more sense this time than it did when I poked it a year or so ago. I downloaded Freemind and used it to sketch out some plans for my current courses. It wasn’t exactly a revelatory experience, and while I’ve continued to play with a bit I can tell that “new toy sheen” is beginning to wear off.

One of my main concerns/disappointments/realizations was one shared by Bill: These “mind maps” are really just plain old-fashioned outlined with some pretty (or, really, not so) pictures laid on top. Freemind sorta allows you to break out of the standard outline mode (one parent, zero or more children; a plain old tree in computing parlance), but that bits pretty weak, and in the end you just have an outline with some decorations. As Bill put it:

And I look at the results, and I see: A rooted tree. An outline. A strict hierarchy. A homogeneous classification diagram. A bundle of undifferentiated hard constraints. A simple Venn Diagram made difficult and misleading by the addition of geographical information.

So what’s the point? Why not just make lists or outlines?

So, with a not terribly convinced tone in his voice, I will suggest a possible argument in favor of mind maps: They do (or at least can) have different affordances (in Norman’s sense of the word) than an outline. Sure, I can presumably write an outlining tool that allows all kinds of cool dragging and (re)connecting, but that’s not how I think about outlines. Dragging crap around and playing with the connections comes entirely naturaly (to me at least) in the realm of graphs. And maybe that’s enough of a difference? Or maybe it’s just an argument for writing more drag-around-friendly outlining tools. (Lord knows that Freemind is hardly a rocket science impressive piece of software. It wouldn’t take a ton to equal or better it.)

None of which addresses Bill’s other concern about the planarity of the darn things, but that’s all I got for now. Sorry. I’ll probably keep playing with Freemind for at least a while longer, but it’s not clear if I’ll still be firing it up at the end of the semester. We’ll see.

They actually convicted Amero?!?


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

Julie Amero, a seventh grade substitute teacher in Connecticut, was just convicted of “impairing the morals of a child”. Apparently a computer in the classroom got stuck in an uncontrolled sequence of porn pop-ups, she became predictably flustered, and couldn’t immediately figure out how to fix the problem. As a consequence some jr. high kids were momentarily exposed to the web’s dark side (which many of them have probably been exploring in much more detail on their own), and Ms. Amero is potentially looking at jail time.

For a nice discussion visit PeeZed (where I first learned of it); for a news report go to this story in a Connecticut newspaper.

This really struck a chord with me, because I had something like this happen to me in my office several years ago. I was helping a student find something on-line, and we got trapped by a porn site with a domain name similar to a “real” site (like the old whitehouse.com scam). The pop-ups started flying everywhere, coming up way faster than I could close them. The whole mess was chewing up so much of my computer’s resources that it took what seemed like forever to get to a place where I could kill my browser. I was mortally embarrassed. Luckily the student thought it was just damned funny, but I kept thinking about distressing it would be if something like that happened in front of a class full of students. I’ve taken pop-up blocking very seriously ever since.

That Ms. Amero might get jail time because of something like this is (to me) pretty terrifying. As PeeZed pointed out in his post, she’s essentially being convicted of not being super computer literate.

It is the 21st century, after all — lack of expertise with a computer is a crime, here in the future.

Way creepy.