Paul Nelson: My new un-poster child

As Pharyngula reported earlier, UMM’s InterVarsity Christian Fellowship played host to Paul Nelson of the pro-intelligent design/creationist Discovery Institute (I’m not dignifying Nelson and the DI with links – you can Google for them if you care).

I have lots I could say (I have several pages of notes), and I’ll try to get to at least some of that later, but I figured I needed to say at least a little bit now to tide Brent over until I can provide a fuller report.

For now I’ll simply say that Paul Nelson is my new poster child for why degrees really don’t mean half of what academics try to make of them. He may have a PhD from the University of Chicago (which, on the surface, is about as good as credentials get), but he’s not very wise. He’s extremely clever, but not very wise. WeatherGirl‘s grandfather had to leave school at 14 to help his family, but was one of the wisest people I’ve had the pleasure of meeting, and was certainly heads and shoulders beyond tonight’s speaker.

Some observations:

  • It was pretty scary to see how clever a speaker he was, because it certainly makes clear how powerful the forces of ignorance can be. We had best not underestimate these people.
  • On the other hand, I was amazed at how much Nelson was willing to concede. (He totally believes, for example, in micro-evolution, but will not accept that lots of micro-evolution adds up to macro-evolution.) There’s an almost desparate feel to ceding so much ground, and it seems a clear sign of how much the many successes of scientific research have carved into the many “unexplainable mysteries” that people like this so desparately need.
  • Our UMM students did a great job of representing the forces of good sense and scientific reason. The bulk of the Q&A was driven by excellent student questions, and while the faculty did get their oars in now and again, the students did a great job and arguably didn’t need us much :-). Well done!
No tag for this post.

Related posts

Phantom lives on in song!

Last night was the monthly CAC Concerts Open Mic Night. Sub-Evil Boy was able to join me because he didn’t have school today (Good Friday, or Spring Break in more religiously neutral terms), which was a lot of fun.

Eagan MC’ed this time and did a very nice job. I really liked his opening set of songs, including an fine rendition of the classic “Drunkard’s special”. Later (after very nice pieces by Grace and a woman who does English folks songs on the recorder, penny whistle, etc.) John H. did a duet with Huck on “The William” (or two of them more accurately) which was pretty crazy and totally fun.

John and I then sang “An American folk song”, which was two instrumental verses through of Guthrie‘s “This land is your land” (John on guitar and me on harmonica) ending with us singing the one verse about private property that no one ever sings. (Guthrie himself rarely sang it on recorded versions of the song; I have four different recordings of him singing this song, and only one has that verse.) The instrumental part went really well, but the mic levels were pretty whack when we got to the vocal part and I think our vocals came out as distorted mud (and not in a way that was intended or necessarily desirable). Sigh.

Joey then did a couple of songs which Sub-Evil Boy really liked. The (new?) one about the ghost of his great-great-great-grandfather making calls on his cell phone was really cool – one of his best in my opinion. He’s going to be performing live on KUMM tonight somewhere between 9pm and midnight, which should be cool.

Sub-Evil and I were right after Joey. Sub-Evil had been nearly asleep in the back, so I was a little worried, but he totally came alive when we got “on stage”. It’s quite amazing (and wonderful) how powerfully he responds to an opportunity to perform in public.

We did two songs that we’d written together last year: “Phantom, the Three Neuron Dog” and “Hey, hey, fat fly”. “Phantom, the Three Neuron Dog” was for my sister when her wonderful dog Phantom died last December, and as such required a certain amount of introduction (who are Julian and Turq, for example?). We’ve never performed it in public before, and it went over really well (esp. for a song that’s very specific to our family), with several nice laughs from the audience. When we were rehersing last night Sub-Evil Boy broke into a can-can dance during the chorus after the 4th verse, and WeatherGirl and I thought it was really funny so he did it again at the performance. The floor in that space is flat and (despite the huge growth spurt he’s in) Sub-Evil Boy isn’t yet 6 foot 2, and it was fun watching the people in the back bobbing and weaving to see what everyone in the front was giggling about.

Phantom lives!

Sub-Evil and I also did “Hey, hey, fat fly”, which we wrote last summer for a community theater project. I’d sung it at the open mic night two months ago to good response, but had never sung it in public with Sub-Evil before, as I was in NYC at the ConBio conference with my sister when the group performed it in August. Earlier in the evening he’d been pretty lukewarm about performing it with me, but once he got on the stage and the energy kicked in and he was totally good to go. I flubbed the third verse (left out a line, and ended up running out of words before I ran out of music), but we recovered well and headed off to the next chorus. The audience response was really nice, but who wouldn’t love a 5th grader singing goofy songs in public?

We stayed for Huck’s set, which included a great song about wanting to be a rock star. I’m not sure if it’s a cover or an original, but either way it was a total hoot.

Sub-Evil was dying by then (it was 11pm) so we bailed and headed home. Who knows what wonderful stuff we missed after that?

I really enjoyed performing with Sub-Evil and hope that we get to do more of that in the future!

No tag for this post.

Related posts