Warning: Constant ABSPATH already defined, this will be an error in PHP 9 in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-config.php on line 22
Events – Page 62 – I am … unhindered by talent

Is piling up patents really a good measure of success?


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

IBM 64-bit core memory chip
The keynote speaker tonight at MICS is from IBM and is extoling the very significant accomplishments of IBM over the years. He’s chosen, however, to place significant emphasis on how many patents are generated by IBM. They apparently consistently lead in the # of patents generated per company in the U.S., and their presence in Rochester, MN, contributes to Rochester often topping the charts of highest per capita patents in the States.

But is this really a good thing? In the early days of IBM’s work in computing, the bulk of IBM’s patents would have been hardware, which is pretty reasonable. Increasingly, though, these are software patents, which just isn’t a happy thing. To quote Don Knuth:

I strongly believe that the recent trend in patenting algorithms is of benefit only to a very small number of attorneys and inventors, while it is seriously harmful to the vast majority of people who want to do useful things with computers.

Given IBM’s current crucial ties with open source initiatives, it seems particularly unfortunate that their long standing corporate culture continues to extol practices that work directly against the open growth and development of both the field and the public cultures surrounding them.

Greetings from MICS 2007


Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_REFERER" in /home/unhinder/www/www/Phi/wp-content/plugins/google-hilite.php on line 58

Teamwork
We’ve arrived without incident in Grand Forks, ND, for MICS 2007. To be blunt, I tend to not come to MICS very often because the quality of the presentations generally isn’t very impressive (not the best examples of scientists as great communicators, I’m afraid).

We have four UMM student talks at this year’s conference, including a talk by two students I’ve been working with on the impact of geography and local mating on diversity in evolutionary computation. Elena set up an evening practice session Wednesday where we could to see and provide feedback on the four talks, and they were quite impressive, so I’m quite confident about those presentations.

Unfortunately, I’m not so confident concerning the other presentations, and the PowerPoint Phluff alone may induce an aneurysm before we’re done. We’re currently being droned at by a panel of industry people talking about the state of the field (or some such – not clear what the point of this is), and a guy from Rockwell Collins just did his darnest to make interesting material really unfocused and hard to listen to. Sigh. The next guy (from Great Plains/Microsoft) was much more interesting, and seemed to have a point and focus. And thus we have what is likely to be a microcosm of the weekend.

Quote for the day: “If you don’t do at least a billion dollars in sales, you’re really just a rounding error at Microsoft.” Yikes! Sadly these industry guys all seemed to see this as a recruiting opportunity at least as much as a chance to share information with their audience.

They have good wireless, though, so if nothing else I can catch up on e-mail and bury you in content free bored-conference-blogging :-).